Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
RayParticipant
good follow-up article about the vietnam vet and that show:
http://www.news-record.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20071002/NRSTAFF/71001023
RayParticipantthank you paul. it takes someone from LA to report what’s happening in NY. 😯
stumbled on this blog while waiting for reports of the show — click on the lucinda photo for a recording from that night of Bus to Baton Rouge — including a talk/rap about the house, her mother, and mental illness. Moving — and emotional, as Paul said.
http://krupsjustsayin.blogspot.com/2007/10/mp3-monday.html
RayParticipantyeah — and that utica crowd would have liked him, I think. He is just like the article describes him. I couldn’t have been happier meeting him on the street at the Keswick show, and having him tell me one of those corny jokes! 🙂
RayParticipantpoint taken, jackstraw — opinions are opinions. But if the show “sucks that bad” as modulus said, then a major newspaper review, written by an experienced reviewer outside of this forum, might just hint at that. It did not. I should’ve carefully said the review didn’t reinforce his opinion! 😉 Anyway, the show really was great, IMHO. 😀
RayParticipantVisions – thanx for posting that starledger review. it pretty much undermines Modulus’ comments. People either “get” lucinda right away, and love her… or they don’t. If they don’t, well, they are the ones who miss a lot of what’s beautiful in this world.
I’ve learned not to argue or try to persuade anymore; it’s a waste of time.
Amy, your comments are so moving. I, too, feel privileged every time I see and hear Lu perform. We are fortunate, in that moment, to witness an artist create something beautiful out of thin air.
Maybe i was in the sweet spot in that theatre (8th row, center, right), but I thought the sound was great. (I was closer at the Pennsylvania show the night before, and had been told the acoustics were great there too, but i found the sound much better at the Shea.)
I’d only disagree about two other things: I think lu’s voice has gotten better — i love her younger voice, but this gravelly, full, more mature voice kills me. 8)
And I think this nation could use a peaceful revolution about now. (Maybe a peaceful, loving revolution.)
RayParticipantInside Job: that is great news, indeed! Thanks for the correction and update. (Did i misunderstand what she said in Pennsylvania? She made some comment on the frustration of the music business and the album being out of print. My apologies if I heard it wrong.)
I definitely look forward to getting the deluxe version when it is released…. In the meantime, as an alternative, the LA live recording of that album night is just wonderful. 😀
RayParticipantIs it just the “lucinda effect” — or are these the best, most true, most beautiful concert recordings ever? I am blown away.
I think i might get impatient, and skip ahead to a favorite song, but i can’t — I am completely pulled into the moment, every moment, on these recordings.
I feel like I am in LA, totally connected with the audience and performance.
And these CDs were cut on the fly, the night of each concert? Whoa. That is incredible. But it’s worked so beautifully — not only is the sound quality excellent, the immediacy is there, the authenticity of lucinda, the band, the guests, the audience — it is just amazing. Thank you for not “polishing” or re-editing these recordings. Thank you for including the so-called false starts, the “figuring it out – live” quality. This is all i want to listen to now — I can’t get back to work! Thank you for sharing it with us. These recordings are a national treasure. 8)
Will i drop another $80 for the nyc sets? without even hesitating.
Memo to recording industry execs: I have seen the future of your business. This is it.
RayParticipantlucinda mentioned this problem in her 9/26 show at the Keswick Theatre. She said she wanted to see the album re-released, but they weren’t doing it and would not sell the rights back to her… She threw up her arms and said something dismissive about the “music business”. 👿
RayParticipantPostscript — should mention that during the encore with Charlie, on Get Right With God, lu starts dancing (in a country hoe-down kind of way), goes over to Butch, picks up some sticks and starts wailing away with him on drums and cymbals for the last, jammin minute or two of the song. That was fun! 😀
RayParticipanti think lu and the band are so primed for nyc…. She needn’t worry. I just wish i could get to more than one of the shows.
thanks, visions, for that title. 🙂
the quality of the sound in that space was just breathtaking….
RayParticipantthanks Keith! I lost track, what with a brewpub across the street and all…
RayParticipantthe show at the keswick definitely rocked. In fact, a few songs in, lu asked the audience if they wanted a more “intellectual” set, or more rock. She heard “rock” and said she’d change things around. It seemed that she had a much more sedate, softer setlist planned for the night, and just abandoned it and did the rest of the show totally on the fly. A ripping, crowd-pleasing show ensued! If the Keswick wasn’t a sit-down theatre, the audience would have been dancing and moving.
Didn’t take notes, and foolishly listened to the LA cds on the long drive home ($80 happily contributed to the fund for all 5) — so my mind’s a big musical blur now — if someone else has the set list as played, i’d love seeing it. (INSIDE JOB : I’d love to see what was planned, too. Look forward to the posting….)
Introducing Are You Allright, Lucinda mentioned Imus playing that song (“turns out he is a big fan of my music; he was good for something after all!”) the Greensboro show and letter from the viet vet who heard Imus play the song, and talked about how there’s now a moving story to go with it. (Acknowledged men & women in uniform!) Mentioned her brother, “the prodigal son”, for whom she wrote the song.
There were some rough spots. “The book” — the “security blanket” — seemed more critical than ever, a few lyrics were missed, a few re-starts, a little rambling — but the audience embraced her warmly — lots of standing up to applaud, song after song. I think it was on Unsuffer Me near the end of the show that she missed some words, but told the guys to keep playing. As has been said here before, these things just make her all the more endearing. She clearly wanted to get everything right, and talked about how wonderful the LA shows were, but was concerned that the critics, when she gets to NY will not be forgiving.
Early on, she kind of regrouped with Out of Touch (wondering if there was anything to read into that choice, at that point…) and got into Metal Firecracker, Come On, Joy (with Riders on the Storm), Those 3 Days, Righteously, Honey Bee, Are You Down, Unsuffer Me. (not in order — and what did i forget? Feel free to correct, y’all.) Pineola, one of my favorites, was in there somewhere early.
The performance was unquestionably high energy. Here at tail end of the tour (what is it — 7 months into it?), you might expect to see signs of fatigue. But her great voice, awesome band, amazing talent shone through. And I couldn’t count the number of times I heard people shout out, We Love You Lucinda. I echo that sentiment here. 😀
nice encore with charlie –get right with god, and an absolutely sweet, beautiful, soft duet on one of the louvin bros. songs… plus i live my life, the fats domino song — so appropriate.
the delightful charlie louvin met folks outside on the street before the show, during his show mentioned their names and meeting and posing for photos, and said he wished he could meet everybody there! A gentleman, a class act, and an honor to hear him live. (BTW, saw him checking out a tricked-out pickup truck with a father and son outside before the show!)
looking toward tonight’s NJ show, final show before NYC…. Rock on, Lu!
8)RayParticipantAnd, ripley, I forgot the emoticons, but meant that last sentence in a nonjudgmental and friendly sort of way. 🙂
RayParticipantWell, yes, Ripley, on that old ACL show Lucinda has a different appearance (mainly darker hair), but that was a decade ago. To demonstrate her integrity, should she hold onto the same look she had when she played on Bourbon Street in the 70s? (Can Inside job post an old snapshot, please? 🙂 ) If you’re performing in the music business, especially if you are female, appearances are part of the game, fair or not. And you can call that marketability — I’ll give you that. We could hold focus groups about which Lu look is preferred, but that’s all superficial, and my point was about the integrity of the music, the songs, and the creative process.
In her songwriting and recording, she is a wonderful example of how to confound any cohesive marketing effort. I admire that. It takes courage and strength to say I’m not going to play the game by the rules of the corporate culture — maybe I’ll change my hair, but not my songs! I still don’t think there is a genre for her — not even “cutting-edge country”, as you say. And if she is becoming an alternate-route role model — and maybe getting comfortable in that role — well, that’s great for everyone.
I don’t think it is, or should be, “beneath” any artist to try something different, to experiment. I think that’s brave. Because you could fail in the eyes of your public.
None of us know what’s going on inside Lucinda’s head, but I have to believe, based on her past, that the songwriting flows without any effort to appeal to any particular audience, demographic, or market. That’s what I mean by “pure.” The creative process is organic, not contrived. I’m not saying she doesn’t care what fans and reviewers think. But I’d like to think that when lyrics and music flow from her head to paper, she could care less.
Can’t a “crowd-pleaser” like Joy also be written from the heart, and be just plain fun to perform? Why is that, or Honey Bee, or Come On, beneath her?
I can tell you have very high standards for Lucinda, and she’s earned that expectation, but maybe you should also just let Lu be Lu.
RayParticipantI’ll second that, Rachel. Really, it is amazing that Lucinda and the band are doing this intense, grueling tour, and night after night the reviews are great (even the impartial media stories). I mean, she should have bad nights! She’s entitled to them. But the worst that happens is a so-called false start. So what. I really enjoy hearing the enthusiastic posts — so many people join
this site just to say they are amazed by the shows (check out Bossier City!). I can’t wait to see a live show again… soon! 😀
IJ, thanks for sharing the inside perspective. I think most of us probably figured as much. -
AuthorPosts