Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
RayParticipant
Yes, Ray–but can I take the both of them in a three-way battle royal, if it comes to that?!?!?
STEEL CAGE DEATH MATCH. NO HOLDS BARRED. THIS HAS PAY-PER-VIEW WRITTEN ALL OVER IT. ❗the Cha-Cha in Ra -cha-cha? The Scenario on Ontario? Whoa dudes, I’m glad i only asked the merch girl for a Buick6 CD — I don’t want to step into this! (Don’t scare her off so that this summer she’s selling t-shirts for Neko… 😮 )
Wish I could join you all. Love that part of the country, snow and ice and rusty belts and all. Last call for Lu before a long trip down under… Should be great. Enjoy! Full reports expected.
RayParticipantwhen I talked to Susannah in montclair, she was very impressed that stoger (only she used his real name) was her most frequent visitor at shows (she brought it up!) — but i’m sure lefty and tim can make an impression too!
RayParticipantThanks for the setlist and reports… I was awaiting Tim’s review of the “new” Buick 6…
I enjoyed the show, but there is a hole there without Doug Pettibone. The “essence” of Lu’s music is missing.
Tim, you are definitely right about the hole. You can’t see a show now and not feel Doug’s absence. I join in singing all the praises of doug that have been posted here, and agree that Lucinda’s band the last few years was amazing. Yet it’s possible the new incarnation of Buick 6 could bring out more of Lucinda in other ways. The show I saw in Montclair put a focus back on Lucinda, who was more subtle and nuanced than I was expecting.
Everything changes and evolves, and thus Lu gets new creative opportunities to keep it fresh.
It’s early to judge how the band is going to sound down the road. I was not disappointed with the band. I am looking forward to hearing how they sound next time i get to a show.
I think the “essence” is Lucinda. (Of course, I’d pay full ticketbastard prices to see her even if she lost her entire band and was out there all by herself with just an acoustic guitar.) 🙂
RayParticipanti promise to always do my part — standing, swaying, shouting, and dancing (but also “well-behaved in a good way, not a boring way” !) 8)
i am liking these current setlists…
RayParticipantShe then observed too much empty space (about 10 feet) between the stage and first row of the seated audience; accordingly, Lucinda asked the audience to stand, move-up, and fill-in the empty space. Consequently, the remainder of the show had a large group standing, swaying, and dancing in front of the stage.
further evidence (proof) that lucinda likes — needs — a standing GA audience up close (as smartly observed by Lafayette in another recent thread)….
Thanks Paul. Any contrasts between Montclair and Peekskill (other than a coat check)?
RayParticipantLafayette: Very thoughtful, considered, controlled response; nicely done. I have to agree: at a LW show (and at a JCM concert, I am sure), nothing compares to standing, floor, GA for both the audience and artist. Magic can happen in this space.
It’s an experience that isn’t quite the same in a seat. And it’s a way for fans to give back, immediately, to the artist.
Sure, not everyone can (or wants to) stand for long periods, so seating is important too. But the Wellmont offered the best of both worlds last night. I thought it was a perfect venue for Lucinda. (Maybe the only thing better would be a similar space outside on a warm summer night.)
BTW, you’ve been a great ambassador for JCM at this forum, and I will say, freely, happily, and publicy: i like the SMART mellencamp fans, and you are clearly one of those. Thanks for your thoughtful contributions! 8)
RayParticipantin my fogginess this morning, replaying last night in my head, i’ll add that “moving” is a good description to add to this show. Although Lucinda played a lot of songs, she avoided many of her “greatest hits”. But the setlist was wondrous, and it created an experience that had surprising layers of emotion and feeling.
I have to say I love the Wellmont. Visions is right about audience and stage — so close! And if you don’t want to stand, the GA balcony seating seems close enough. A bar with good beer, too! Something for everybody, really.
Although the break between Buick6 and Lu’s appearance seemed long, I would have loved for the show to go on into the wee hours. No complaints from me about staying out late for Lu!! It even felt like she might have done a 3rd encore, if the crowd had only asked.
All the silly, superficial issues from the past (“the book,” etc) seem to have faded into the irrelevant distance.
i remember Amy’s comments about Lu’s sign-off from the last nj show in sept ’07, and she’s right: no need for revolution anymore, just peace and love.
RayParticipanttime change or not, i’m up, still running on garden state parkway rest area coffee soo…
Visions has an accurate setlist. The Chet joined Lu on Side of the Road. Eric played mandolin on People Talking. The 2nd encore was a very nice surprise; quite a few had already headed for the exits, and turned around to hear the Hendrix song, Sweet Angel — a beautiful Lu solo; she mentioned a birthday (bridgette?) — didn’t quite catch this full reference….
Lovely show — abt 2 hrs, starting at around 9:20. Overheard someone on the way out say it was “long — just like the old days..” (well, it wasn’t a 4 hr show, but still it seemed full, 24 songs, and a lot of the catalog was covered )
I was thinking that this standing venue, and crowd, might kick Lu into a rockin’ show. But it was not to be, although by the end, Honeybee and Come On had the crowd moving, as did Long Way to the Top and Joy in the encore.
Just my observation, but it seemed Lu was a bit subdued. Not in a mood, but just kind of inwardly reflective perhaps, for a good part of the show. Whatever, it only added to a more intimate feel, and drew us in. She warmed up, seemed to genuinely appreciate the audience, and the Wellmont acoustics too (“great sounding room”).
Lu rapped briefly about the ticket charges, how she is a “natural born rebel” and fighting the surcharges, and thanked all for spending their hard earned-money to come out.
No sliver of midriff tonight — Lu was dressed in a black subtly striped top, over a black shirt and beige corduroys. With her new dark hair, i had a flash of Chryssie Hynde. Lu with a hint of punk! I like it.
Susannah, the merch girl, seemed pleased to know that she and her table have become part of the postings here. Bought a Buick6 CD…
OK, coffee’s rapidly wearing off. I think the time change has already occurred! G’night.
RayParticipantthanks Vis. Great report. Acoustics at the Keswick are excellent (saw her there with the wonderful Charlie Louvin in sept 07), but the formal seating creates a more sedate crowd. It’ll be interesting to see how/if the energy changes tonight with standing GA on the floor. Looking forward to a great show at the “new” Wellmont. If I see the middle-aged guy reaching for the setlist, I’ll say hi! 😛
RayParticipantwashington post review blog of the first night at the 9:30 club:
http://voices.washingtonpost.com/postrock/2009/03/live_last_night_lucinda_willia.htmlmost interesting are these two reader comments at the bottom of the review:
Comments
I must say, for Lucinda fans I think the Tuesday show probably trended more toward “one for the books.” It was one for me.
Sure, I would have preferred a few more up-tempo numbers and a few more of my personal favorites mixed in. But what really speaks to the show’s quality is how much I really enjoyed some of the songs I’ve never cared for that much on her records. The band put real meat on some that have never seemed quite there, while the vast majority of the down-tempo songs were just gorgeous. Just think: have you ever heard the 9:30 Club that silent? That says a lot, to me.
Posted by: freshprince04 | March 4, 2009 3:44 PM
Have to agree with previous comment. I’m not fond of People Talking recorded; live it was extraordinary. The quality of Lucinda’s voice and Buick 6’s drummer made last night one for the books. Song selection was perfect, minus I Envy, but Overtime will suffice in lieu. The Honey Bee song live– again, who knew? And they ate at Nathans– I’m sorry but I have to give the props at the altar of Lucinda.
Posted by: sjordan1 | March 4, 2009 5:55 PM
RayParticipantthat looks like fun, though in a way much scarier than a wall of crucifixes….
RayParticipantthanks for the alert gravel roads. I went and got my NYT mag, and turned right to p. 17. Funky, eclectic, and cozy — thanks for inviting us in, Lu and Tom. Fascinating new anecdotes too: all those crystals –wow (maybe offer them on ebay) — and Lucinda doing sausage demonstrations in stores! who knew? 😯 (talk about paying your dues…)
hope to catch the PA or NJ shows next weekend. I’m excited by the awesome reports of the current tour from the south…
RayParticipantthat story in today’s Times, with the line Tom references, begins with a mention of Lucinda’s father as only one of the four Presidential inaugural poets:
“Miller Williams seemed to get it about right. His inaugural poem, “Of History and Hope,” was dignified, with a weather-beaten resonance. It began:
We have memorized America,
how it was born and who we have been and where.
In ceremonies and silence we say the words,
telling the stories, singing the old songs.(Music fans could not have heard that last line without recalling that Mr. Williams is the father of Lucinda Williams, the venerated singer and songwriter.)
“To have great poetry there must be great audiences, too,” Walt Whitman said. He was talking about the quality of a poet’s readers. “
(“venerated” — how about that for an adjective for Lucinda?!!)
Good story. Good to see poetry take center stage. Good to be a part of the audience.
Thanks for a year of great music — and for letting us be a part of it. Looking forward to the shows in the new year.
Happy christmas/hanukkah/kwanzaa/druid rituals/and new year to all! (May the Pagans and Christians enjoy the holiday table together.)
RayParticipanthttp://www.nytimes.com/2008/11/30/arts/television/30ryzi.html?ref=music
Though Sundance executives made suggestions about guests, along the lines of Beyoncé, in the end Mr. Costello, Mr. Furnish and Mr. John made most of the invitations themselves. “Not everybody that plays an instrument is actually that interesting,” Mr. Costello said.
Mr. John added, “I just wanted to make a deeply intelligent set of programs that, in years to come, people can look back on as a historical reference.”
Despite that shared interest in history, after more than three decades in the music business Mr. Costello was tiring of pop stardom himself; last year he was telling friends that he was done making records. “And I really believed it,” he said. “It wasn’t so much the making the record, it was all the other nonsense.” Instead he made guest appearances on albums by Lucinda Williams, Jenny Lewis — she’s also on the show — and Fall Out Boy. That last request came as a surprise: “I didn’t even know they existed,” he said. (He agreed, he said, because they seemed sincere.)
RayParticipantI’ve often thought it is interesting that Lucinda and Hank share last names and that — I can’t put it any better than Elvis — she shares “Hank’s kind of economy for just the right amount of words and in exactly the right order.” It is a great description for both of their songwriting.
It’s even more interesting when you add Lucinda’s father, Miller Williams, a poet, into the ruminations…. As a further digression, here’s a choice excerpt from an interview with the father, where he notes the shared last name (http://www.jimnewsom.com/PFW05-MillerWilliams.html):….but one of his favorite memories is an evening spent with country music legend Hank Williams.
“In 1952,” he remembered, “I was teaching at McNeese State College in Lake Charles, Louisiana, and Lucinda was just on her way in the womb. He and the Drifting Cowboys performed at McNeese and after it was over, they were up on the stage by themselves—the audience was gone and they were putting their instruments away. I stepped up onstage, and he looked at me and said, ‘Yeh?’ I said, ‘Mr. Williams, my name is Williams and I just wanted to tell you you’re the best there is.’ And he said, ‘Anywhere around here to get a drink?’
“In those days you could get a drink at an Esso station; they had booths. I said, ‘Yeh, just a few blocks down the street.’ He said, ‘Tell my driver where,’ and I did.
“We went in my car, and he sat facing the door so he could see when his driver came in. He ordered some beer. It was my first college teaching job and though I was an instructor, I thought of myself as a college professor—I was only 22—and I said, ‘Well, I think I’ll have a Scotch.’ Because that’s what college professors drink.
“So I had a Scotch and he had more than one beer; we were just chatting about all sorts of things. His driver showed up, so he stood up and walked past me in the booth. He put his hand on my shoulder, looked down and said, ‘you oughtta drink beer, Williams, ‘cause you got a beer drinking soul.’ And I haven’t had a Scotch since!
“He died right after that in that same car, about two weeks after we met. [Hank Williams died on New Year’s Day, 1953.] And Lucinda was born on January 26th.”
-
AuthorPosts